The sweet spot.
Caramels made the old-fashioned way with locally sourced butter, milk, and cream? Count us in. Everything here was slow-cooked to perfection in a bona fide copper kettle, then lovingly packaged with a refurbished vintage cutting and wrapping machine (yep). Wondering about gluten, nuts, soy, or artificial flavors? You won’t find any of that here.
Snag a set for the candy lover in your life (and we won’t tell if you keep it for yourself):
Salted Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Black Lava Sea Salt, Cape Cod Sea Salt, and Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt.
Caffeinated Caramel Sampler: 2 pillow boxes each of Deep Chocolate, Dark Roasted Mocha, and Café Noir.
Taste of the Northeast Gift Set: 1 tube each of Cape Cod Sea Salt and Tapped Maple.
Traditional Favorites Gift Set: 1 tube each of Classic Vanilla and Deep Chocolate.
Unexpected Flavors Gift Set: 1 tube each of Black Lava Sea Salt and Single Malt Scotch
.
Party Box: A medley of four different flavors—Classic Vanilla, Black Lava Sea Salt, Deep Chocolate, or Tapped Maple—in a small or large size (depending on how long you want the party to last).
Variety Set: For the true caramel connoisseur, this box has about 4 pieces each of 9 different flavors: Dark Roasted Mocha, Ginger Fusion, Rosemary Truffle Sea Salt, Single Malt Scotch, Black Lava Sea Salt, Tapped Maple, Cape Cod Sea Salt, Classic Vanilla, and Deep Chocolate.
Photography by Julia Gartland & Ty Mecham
Meet the Maker
McCrea's Candies
Our Tips & Stories
How we'd use this beauty in our own homes.

How to Make Real Caramel Sauce at Home
Your ice cream called. It wants to be covered in the kind of gooey, warm caramel sauce that puts store-bought varieties to shame. Lucky for you (and your ice cream), Alice is demonstrating how you can make that happen.

How to Make Creamy, Melty Fudge (The Best Last-Minute Gift)
Oh, fudge! Who knew candy-making could be so easy?

Why You Should Make Rocky Road at Home (But Buy Marshmallows)
The easiest DIY candy for Halloween.
Be the first to write a review!
Purchased this product? Let us know what you think!
You can submit a review for any product you’ve purchased here.
A Similar Style
Elsewhere on Food52
Today’s Top Story

So Hot Right Now

Weeknight Cooking
We Asked 25,000 Home Cooks for Their Trustiest Weeknight Dinners
Off-Script With Sohla
Sohla's All-in-One Guide to the Ultimate Pound Cake







